Archive for civil unions

A Rose by Any Other Name….? (and an angry email)

In this week’s column at 365gay.com, I address the issue whether civil unions should be considered a serviceable political compromise for the time being, while we await full marriage equality. As you might expect, lots of comments have come in already.
But I wanted to share a very different sort of comment; one that you wouldn’t [...]

Posted by: John Culhane on Thursday, July 8th, 2010

Another Angry Perspective on Lingle’s Veto of Civil Union Legislation

A reader and old friend writes:
Linda Lingle has failed in so many ways, my head is still spinning. When she voiced her commitment to protecting the sanctity of marriage, she failed to mention her 2 divorces.  She failed to fulfill her 2006 campaign promise to not veto legislation on same sex marriage.  She failed as [...]

Posted by: John Culhane on Wednesday, July 7th, 2010

Live Blogging Lingle’s Civil Union Announcement

It’s weird. I’m sitting here looking at the seal of Hawaii, soon to be occluded by the Governor, Linda Lingle, who’s set to make her announcement. I guess this is a live blog….
That seal translates into English, roughly, as “The life of the land is perpetuated in righteousness.” And one of the two figures on [...]

Posted by: John Culhane on Tuesday, July 6th, 2010

Prediction: Lingle Signs Civil Unions Bill

Hawaii Gov. Linda Lingle must decide today whether to sign the civil unions bill enacted by the legislature at the end of April. (Hawaii time is six hours behind EDT, so it’s only 10:30 am there right now).  After wrestling with the issue for more than two months now, this is it: under state law, today’s [...]

Posted by: John Culhane on Tuesday, July 6th, 2010

Civil Unions Coming to Hawaii?

In 1993, the Hawaii Supreme Court seemed on the verge of bringing marriage equality to the state. In Baehr v. Lewin, the court held that the ban on gay marriages was a form of sex discrimination, and that the state therefore bore a heavy burden of justification. The case was sent back to the lower [...]

Posted by: John Culhane on Monday, January 25th, 2010

Reading the Maine Marriage Equality Setback

Let’s face it; this loss in Maine is tough to swallow. Here’s a comment from a despondent reader:
I know after some rest I’ll even out and get back to the business of living, but right now I feel very done with the ballot box, and donating, and phone-banking, and talking myself blue in the face, [...]

Posted by: John Culhane on Wednesday, November 4th, 2009

A Conversation with Alex Nicholson

Here’s something to think about:
Getting married, or civilly united, as a same-sex couple can get you discharged under the military’s “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy. As the New Jersey Civil Union Commission Report pointed out, declaring that you’re in a civil union is actually “worse” (read: more hazardous) than saying “I Got Married!” — since [...]

Posted by: John Culhane on Tuesday, May 19th, 2009

Andrew Sullivan’s “Familiar Feeling” — and a Qualified Defense of Obama

Well, we’re not even four months into the Obama Administration and already the LGBT community is frustrated at the pace of developments. And, really, who can blame us, after the betrayals of the Clinton Administration and the hostility of his successor who-must-not-be-named? Here’s Andrew Sullivan, in a sobering and angry piece on the Atlantic website [...]

Posted by: John Culhane on Thursday, May 14th, 2009

Equality Forum: The International Equality Dinner Starring the One and Only Gavin Newsom

Talk about your gala events! 
Well, for $200 a plate, Saturday night’s International Equality Dinner needed to be a fabulous, star-studded affair, and it was. Pennsylvania Governor Ed Rendell, a true ally of the gay and lesbian community since forever, was Honorary Chair and delivered his usually warm, amusing, and affirming speech. With no elections left [...]

Posted by: John Culhane on Sunday, May 3rd, 2009

Equality Forum Day 3 (Part 2): It’s Always Personal

Family Law is an exciting yet weird course to teach. The law school model (now admittedly under both siege and reconstruction) emphasizes legal reasoning and analysis, the parsing of cases and statutes, and the occasional foray into broader constitutional issues. Of course, very few legal scholars or students today think that a legal result can [...]

Posted by: John Culhane on Thursday, April 30th, 2009